Book Review Summary: Heart: Seed Snow Circuit

Introduction

"Heart: Seed Snow Circuit" by Lucy Knisley is a charming and literary graphic novel that tells the story of a girl who encounters an apple, a snowman, and a refrigerator on a cold day. Each of these characters imparts wisdom about hunger, passion, and love, making for a thought-provoking and engaging read. In this article, we will delve into the author's background, analyze the views of readers, and explore the reasons for both recommending and not recommending this book.

About Lucy Knisley

Lucy Knisley, the author of "Heart: Seed Snow Circuit," is a talented cartoonist with a passion for comics. She grew up in New York City and has always been drawn to the art form. Knisley is a graduate of the School of the Art Institute of Chicago and is currently pursuing an MFA at the Center for Cartoon Studies. Throughout her career, she has honed her skills and gained recognition for her unique style and storytelling abilities. Her love for books, sewing, bicycles, food, and Oscar Wilde are just some of the many interests that inspire her work.

Analysis of Views

Discourse on creativity and creating: Readers who appreciate books that explore the nature of art and creativity often find "Heart: Seed Snow Circuit" thought-provoking and engaging. The conversations between the apple, snowman, refrigerator, and the protagonist provide a unique perspective on the creative process.
Warm and fuzzy feelings: Many readers describe feeling a sense of warmth and comfort while reading this book. The story's simplicity and the characters' wisdom resonate with readers, creating a sense of nostalgia and comfort.
Less personal and less polished: Some readers find that "Heart: Seed Snow Circuit" lacks the personal touch and polish found in Knisley's later works. They note that it feels more like an undergraduate final project than a fully realized work.
Pretentious and amateur-ish: A few readers describe the book as pretentious and amateur-ish, with conversations between inanimate objects feeling forced or contrived. These readers feel that the book could have been more cohesive or focused.
Weirdness factor: While some readers appreciate the quirkiness and uniqueness of "Heart: Seed Snow Circuit," others find it bizarre or off-putting. The inclusion of conversations between an apple, snowman, refrigerator, and a girl may not appeal to all readers.

Reasons for Recommendation

Early work with historical value: As an early work by Lucy Knisley, "Heart: Seed Snow Circuit" offers readers an opportunity to see where she began her career. For fans of her later novels, reading this book can provide insights into her development as an artist and storyteller.
Raw and open storytelling: The book's raw and open nature appeals to readers who appreciate honesty and vulnerability in storytelling. It offers a glimpse into Knisley's early style and allows readers to see her growth as an artist over time.
Engaging conversations: The conversations between the apple, snowman, refrigerator, and the protagonist provide unique insights into different aspects of life, including hunger, passion, and love. These conversations make for an engaging read that encourages introspection and reflection.

Reasons for Not Recommendation

Lack of cohesiveness: Some readers find that "Heart: Seed Snow Circuit" lacks cohesiveness or direction, making it difficult to fully engage with the story. The inclusion of conversations between inanimate objects may not resonate with all readers, leading to a disconnect between the characters and the narrative.
Pretentiousness: A few readers feel that the book's pretentious nature detracts from its overall appeal. The conversations between an apple, snowman, refrigerator, and a girl may come across as forced or contrived, leading to a lack of authenticity in the storytelling.

Conclusion

"Heart: Seed Snow Circuit" by Lucy Knisley is a charming graphic novel that explores themes of creativity, hunger, passion, and love through conversations between an apple, snowman, refrigerator, and a girl. While some readers appreciate its raw and open nature, others find it less polished or pretentious. As an early work by Knisley, it offers insights into her development as an artist and provides a unique perspective on the creative process. Whether you are a fan of Lucy Knisley's later novels or simply looking for a quick read with a touch of quirkiness, "Heart: Seed Snow Circuit" may be worth exploring for its historical value and engaging conversations.