Book Review Summary: Stay Me, Oh Comfort Me: Journals and Stories, 1933-1941

Introduction

"Stay Me, Oh Comfort Me: Journals and Stories, 1933-1941" is a captivating collection of journals and stories by the renowned American writer M.F.K. Fisher. This second volume of reminiscences delves into Fisher's personal life, exploring her resilience, observations, humor, and lifelong love for good food and drink. Through her writings, Fisher transports readers to California in the late 1930s and 1940s, offering a glimpse into a bygone era while also sharing her intimate experiences.

About M.F.K. Fisher

Mary Frances Kennedy Fisher, better known as M.F.K. Fisher, was a prolific writer who left an indelible mark on the literary world. With over 20 books to her name, Fisher's works primarily focused on food and its cultural significance. Her writing style was characterized by her vivid descriptions, evocative language, and exploration of the art of living. Fisher's ability to capture the essence of life through her writing has made her a beloved figure among readers.

Analysis of Views

1. Personal and Intimate: Readers appreciate the personal nature of this collection, as it offers a glimpse into Fisher's life during a challenging period. The journals reveal her struggles with her marriage and the health of her husband, providing readers with a deeper understanding of her experiences.
2. Engaging Writing Style: M.F.K. Fisher's writing style is highly praised for its rhythmic language and evocative descriptions. Readers find her writing mesmerizing and often feel as if they know her personally from the insights she shares in her works.
3. Vivid Descriptions: Fisher's ability to paint vivid pictures with her words is a common theme among readers. Her descriptions of places, relationships, and personal experiences transport readers to different times and locations, immersing them in the story.
4. Inspiring and Relatable: Many readers find comfort in Fisher's writings, particularly during difficult times in their own lives. Her honesty and beauty in describing her life experiences inspire readers to live more richly and to express their own thoughts more fully in their writing.
5. Interesting Historical Context: The book offers a fascinating glimpse into California during the late 1930s and 1940s, providing readers with insights into the social and cultural landscape of that era. The historical context adds depth to Fisher's personal stories and makes the book a valuable addition to historical literature.

Reasons for Recommendation

1. Personal Journey: Readers recommend this book for its personal nature, as it offers a unique perspective on M.F.K. Fisher's life during a challenging period. The journals provide an intimate look into her struggles and triumphs, making it relatable and inspiring for those going through similar experiences.
2. Engaging Writing Style: The mesmerizing writing style of M.F.K. Fisher is a major reason for recommending this book. Her evocative language and rhythmic pacing captivate readers and make the reading experience enjoyable and memorable.
3. Vivid Descriptions: The vivid descriptions found in Fisher's writing are highly praised by readers, who appreciate the way she brings places, people, and experiences to life through her words. These descriptions make the book a delightful read for those who appreciate rich imagery and sensory details.

Reasons for Not Recommendation

1. Heartbreaking Content: Some readers find the book too heartbreaking to finish, as it delves into the challenges faced by M.F.K. Fisher during her personal life, particularly the illness and eventual death of her second husband. The sadness expressed in the journals may be overwhelming for some readers who prefer lighter or more uplifting content.
2. Disjointed Structure: A few readers find the book disjointed and difficult to follow due to occasional stories thrown in between journal entries. The lack of cohesion in the structure may make it challenging for readers to fully immerse themselves in the narrative and follow the flow of events.

Conclusion

"Stay Me, Oh Comfort Me: Journals and Stories, 1933-1941" by M.F.K. Fisher is a captivating collection that offers readers a personal glimpse into the life of one of America's most beloved writers. Through her journals and stories, Fisher shares her resilience, observations, humor, and lifelong love for good food and drink. While some readers find the book heartbreaking due to its focus on personal struggles, others appreciate the engaging writing style and vivid descriptions that bring the story to life. Overall, "Stay Me, Oh Comfort Me" is a must-read for those interested in literature, food culture, or simply seeking an intimate look into the life of a talented writer during a transformative period in history.