Quick Take

By the author-and-illustrator team of the bestselling The LibraryLydia Grace Finch brings a suitcase full of seeds, plenty of stationery, and a passion for gardening to the big gray city, where she goes to stay with her Uncle Jim, a cantankerous baker. There she initiates a gradual transformation, brightening the bakery and bringing smiles to customers' faces with the flowers she grows. But it is in a secret place that Lydia Grace works on her masterpiece, which she hopes will be powerful enough to make even Uncle Jim smile. Colored by a Depression-era setting, The Gardener introduces readers to a winsome young heroine, whose generosity will reward all who meet her. The Gardener is a 1997 New York Times Book Review Notable Children's Book of the Year and a 1998 Caldecott Honor Book.

Reader's Review

Book Review Summary: The Gardener

Introduction

"The Gardener" is a children's book written by Sarah Stewart and illustrated by David Small. Set in the 1930s during the Great Depression, the story follows Lydia Grace Finch, a young girl sent to live with her Uncle Jim in the city. Lydia Grace brings her passion for gardening and her suitcase full of seeds, transforming the bakery and bringing joy to those around her. This book is a New York Times Book Review Notable Children's Book of the Year and a Caldecott Honor Book.

About Sarah Stewart

Sarah Stewart, the author of "The Gardener," is a wife of renowned illustrator David Small. She has written several children's books, growing up in Texas and currently residing in Michigan. With her husband's artistic talent, she has created captivating stories that resonate with readers of all ages.

Analysis of Views

Gardening and Simplicity: Readers appreciate the book's focus on gardening and the beauty of simple things in life. Lydia Grace's love for gardening serves as a reminder that happiness can be found in the smallest moments and everyday activities.
Historical Setting: The 1930s Depression era setting adds depth and context to the story. Readers find it captivating to see how Lydia Grace adapts to her new surroundings and brings joy to those around her, even during challenging times.
Engaging Characters: Lydia Grace Finch, the main protagonist, is a relatable and endearing character. Readers enjoy getting to know her and appreciate her determination to make a difference in her uncle's life. The supporting characters, such as Ed and Emma Beech, also contribute to the book's charm.
Illustrations: The illustrations by David Small are praised for their lively and descriptive qualities. They provide a visually stunning complement to Sarah Stewart's narrative, adding depth and emotion to the story.
Inspiring Message: "The Gardener" offers an inspiring message about perseverance and finding joy in life's simple pleasures. Readers find it heartwarming to see how Lydia Grace transforms her uncle's bakery with her gardening skills and brings happiness to those around her.

Reasons for Recommendation

Engaging Storytelling: Sarah Stewart's storytelling skills are commended for their ability to captivate readers from start to finish. The book's pacing and plot development keep readers engaged and invested in Lydia Grace's journey.
Themes of Hope and Resilience: The book's themes of hope and resilience resonate with readers. Lydia Grace's determination to bring joy to her uncle's life during challenging times serves as an inspiration for readers facing their own struggles.
Beautiful Illustrations: David Small's illustrations add depth and emotion to the story, making it visually stunning. The vivid colors and detailed depictions of characters and settings enhance the reading experience.

Reasons for Not Recommendation

Misrepresentation of Uncle Jim: Some readers find Lydia Grace's insistence on making Uncle Jim smile problematic, as it implies that not smiling equates to unhappiness or misery. This aspect of the story may not resonate with all readers.
Limited Depth of Characters: While Lydia Grace is a lovable protagonist, some readers feel that other characters, such as Ed and Emma Beech, are not as well-developed as they could be. This may affect their connection to the story and overall enjoyment of the book.

Conclusion

"The Gardener" by Sarah Stewart and illustrated by David Small is a captivating children's book set during the 1930s Depression era. With its engaging storytelling, beautiful illustrations, and themes of hope and resilience, it resonates with readers of all ages. While some readers may have concerns about certain aspects of the story, such as the portrayal of Uncle Jim or the depth of certain characters, the overall positive reception of "The Gardener" makes it a recommended read for those seeking a heartwarming tale about finding joy in life's simple pleasures.