Book Review Summary: The Orphan Train

Introduction

"The Orphan Train" by Steve Brigman is a captivating historical fiction novel set in the early 20th century. The story revolves around two children, James and Vivian, who meet on one of the infamous trains carrying orphaned children. Separated by adoption, they find each other later in life and together, as outsiders, confront local prejudices and the perils associated with taking a stand. This book has garnered praise from readers for its fine writing, compelling storytelling, and insightful character development. In this article, we will delve into the author's background, analyze the views of readers, and explore the reasons for both recommending and not recommending this book.

About Steve Brigman

Steve Brigman, the author of "The Orphan Train," is a talented novelist with a background in journalism. After a decade as a newspaper editor, he transitioned to freelance writing and began to explore fiction. His second historical novel, "The Old Wire Road," follows "The Orphan Train," both set in the Missouri Ozarks. Brigman's writing style is described as coarse-grained and evocative, drawing readers into the world he creates. His ability to capture the essence of Americana and bring history to life has earned him accolades from readers and critics alike.

Analysis of Views

1. Compelling Historical Fiction: Readers praise the book for its compelling storytelling and insightful character development. The author's ability to delve into the harsh realities of the past while weaving a captivating narrative has been widely appreciated.
2. Well-Researched and Engaging: Many readers find the historical aspect of the book to be well-researched and engaging. The author's attention to detail and ability to capture the nuances of the time period have been commended.
3. Emotional Depth: The book evokes emotions ranging from sadness to joy, making readers invested in the characters' lives. The author's ability to portray complex emotions and relationships adds depth to the story.
4. Engaging Plot: Readers appreciate the book's engaging plot, which keeps them turning pages. The unexpected twists and turns in the story, combined with well-developed characters, make for a thrilling reading experience.
5. Lack of Focus on Orphan Train Experience: Some readers feel that the title is misleading as the book focuses more on the characters' lives after their adoption rather than delving deeply into their experiences on the orphan train. They feel that the title should better reflect the content of the book.
6. Monotonous Description: A few readers find the book's descriptions to be monotonous at times, particularly when it comes to scenery or character development. They feel that these sections could have been more concise or engaging.
7. Lack of Historical Context: Some readers feel that the book could have provided more historical context, particularly when it comes to current events or social issues of the time period. They feel that these elements could have enriched their understanding of the story.
8. Misleading Title: A few readers express disappointment with the title, as it implies a greater focus on orphan trains than what is actually portrayed in the book. They feel that a different title would better reflect the content of the story.

Reasons for Recommendation

1. Compelling Storytelling: Readers recommend "The Orphan Train" for its captivating storytelling and well-developed characters. The author's ability to weave a narrative that keeps readers engaged from start to finish is widely appreciated.
2. Insightful Character Development: The book's characters are praised for their depth and complexity. Readers appreciate the author's ability to portray relatable and believable characters that resonate with them emotionally.
3. Engaging Historical Fiction: The historical aspect of the book is highly recommended by readers who enjoy learning about historical events through fictional narratives. The author's attention to detail and ability to bring history to life make for an engaging reading experience.

Reasons for Not Recommendation

1. Lack of Focus on Orphan Train Experience: Some readers feel that the book does not fully live up to its title, as it focuses more on characters' lives after their adoption rather than delving deeply into their experiences on the orphan train. They feel that a different title would better reflect the content of the book.
2. Monotonous Description: A few readers find certain sections of the book to be monotonous, particularly when it comes to descriptions of scenery or character development. They feel that these sections could have been more concise or engaging.
3. Lack of Historical Context: Some readers feel that the book could have provided more historical context, particularly when it comes to current events or social issues of the time period. They feel that these elements would have enriched their understanding of the story.

Conclusion

"The Orphan Train" by Steve Brigman is a captivating historical fiction novel that explores themes of love, loss, and resilience set against a backdrop of early 20th-century America. The book has garnered praise from readers for its compelling storytelling, well-researched historical aspects, and insightful character development. While some readers feel that certain elements could have been improved, such as a more focused approach on the orphan train experience or additional historical context, overall, "The Orphan Train" is recommended for those who enjoy engaging historical fiction with relatable characters and a captivating narrative.