Book Review Summary: A Cold Case

Introduction

"A Cold Case" is a gripping true-life Manhattan noir that delves into the intricacies of police procedural investigations. Written by Philip Gourevitch, a prize-winning author, this book explores the story of Andy Rosenzweig, a chief investigator for the Manhattan District Attorney's office, and his relentless pursuit of a murder case that had been abandoned by the NYPD decades ago. With its vivid portrayal of urban policing and the complexities of detective work, this book offers a captivating read for fans of true crime.

About Philip Gourevitch

Philip Gourevitch, the author of "A Cold Case," was born in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, to painter Jacqueline Gourevitch and philosophy professor Victor Gourevitch. Gourevitch grew up in Middletown, Connecticut, where his father taught at Wesleyan University. He developed a passion for writing from an early age and eventually graduated from Cornell University. After taking a break to focus solely on writing, Gourevitch published short fiction in literary magazines before turning to non-fiction. His writing style is characterized by its fierce directness and flair for personality that compels readers.

Analysis of Views

Engaging Storytelling: Readers appreciate the book's engaging storytelling, finding it genuinely fascinating and a refreshing return to police work as it is actually practiced by experts in the field. The book's focus on diligent detective work and the ordinary tale of investigation resonates with readers who enjoy a more authentic portrayal of police procedures.
Realistic Portrayal: Many readers find the book's portrayal of police work and the realities of urban policing to be particularly noteworthy. The author's ability to present a flat and very ordinary tale of investigation without melodramatic twists or clinching revelations adds to the book's authenticity and credibility.
Insight into True Crime: Fans of true crime find the book valuable for its insights into the world of criminal investigations. The book provides a glimpse into the challenges faced by detectives in their pursuit of justice and highlights the importance of diligence, persistence, and teamwork in solving crimes.
Character Development: Readers praise the character development in the book, particularly the portrayal of Andy Rosenzweig as a determined investigator. The author's ability to bring to life the personalities of both the investigators and the suspects adds depth and nuance to the story.
Engaging Prose: Gourevitch's writing style is highly praised by readers for its prose that is both captivating and accessible. The author's ability to convey complex information in a straightforward manner makes for an enjoyable reading experience.

Reasons for Recommendation

Compelling True Crime Story: The book's compelling true crime story, combined with its well-researched and well-written narrative, makes it a highly recommended read for fans of true crime. The book offers an authentic portrayal of police work and provides valuable insights into the challenges faced by detectives in their pursuit of justice.
Engaging Storytelling: Readers appreciate the book's engaging storytelling, which keeps them invested in the investigation from beginning to end. The ordinary tale of diligent detective work is presented with fierce directness, making it a refreshing read for those seeking an authentic portrayal of police procedures.
Realistic Portrayal: The realistic portrayal of police work and the complexities of criminal investigations adds credibility to the book's narrative. Readers appreciate the author's ability to present a gripping story without resorting to melodramatic twists or sensationalism, making it a trustworthy source of information on true crime.

Reasons for Not Recommendation

Lack of Melodrama: Some readers find that the book lacks the melodramatic twists and clinching revelations commonly associated with true crime stories. While this realistic portrayal may appeal to some readers, others may feel that it detracts from the excitement and intrigue typically found in this genre.
Length: A few readers express disappointment with the length of the book, feeling that it could have been padded out with more details or additional cases. However, most readers agree that the book's brevity contributes to its authenticity and keeps it from becoming overly sensationalized or formulaic.

Conclusion

"A Cold Case" by Philip Gourevitch is a compelling true crime story that offers an authentic portrayal of police work and criminal investigations. With its engaging storytelling, realistic portrayal, and insightful insights into the world of true crime, this book is highly recommended for fans of the genre. While some readers may find it lacking in melodrama or feel that it could have been longer, overall, "A Cold Case" delivers a captivating read that sheds light on the challenges faced by detectives in their pursuit of justice.