Quick Take

ORPHANED AT THE AGE OF SIX, Jane Williams has grown up in a series of foster homes, learning to survive in the shadows of life. Through hard work and determination, she manages to win a scholarship to the exclusive Birch Grove Academy. There, for the first time, Jane finds herself accepted by a group of friends. She even starts tutoring the headmistress's gorgeous son, Lucian. Things seem too good to be true.They are.The more she learns about Birch Grove, the more Jane comes to suspect that there is something sinister going on. Why did the wife of a popular teacher kill herself? What happened to the former scholarship student whose place Jane took? Why does Lucian's brother, Jack, seem to dislike her so much?As Jane begins to piece together the answers to the puzzle, she must find out why she was brought to Birch Grove-and what she would risk to stay there. . . .

Reader's Review

Book Review Summary: Dark Companion

Introduction

"Dark Companion" by Marta Acosta is a young adult novel that follows the story of Jane Williams, an orphan who has survived a traumatic experience in her childhood. After being offered a full scholarship to Birch Grove Academy, Jane finds herself in a world of secrets and mysteries. As she uncovers the truth about her past and the school's dark secrets, Jane must make difficult choices to protect herself and those she cares about.

About Marta Acosta

Marta Acosta is an author known for her ability to create engaging and well-developed characters. She has a degree in English Literature and Creative Writing from Stanford University, and her writing has appeared in various publications such as the San Francisco Chronicle, the Contra Costa Times, and Spaces Magazine. Marta lives with her husband, spawn, and their crazy dogs. She is an avid gardener, enjoys independent films, and is always happy to hear from her readers.

Analysis of Views

Engaging Characters: Readers praise the character development in "Dark Companion." Jane Williams, the protagonist, is described as a strong and resilient young woman who has overcome adversity. The supporting characters, such as Mary Violet and Jack, are also well-received for their quirky and memorable personalities.
Mysterious Plot: The book's mysterious plot is a key aspect that draws readers in. The story unfolds gradually, with hints of secrets and danger lurking around every corner. Readers appreciate the subtle hints and the gradual reveal of the story's twists and turns.
Gothic Atmosphere: The book's Gothic atmosphere is another aspect that readers appreciate. The dark and eerie setting adds to the suspenseful tone of the story. The book's Gothic elements, such as the missing teacher's wife and the strange rituals, contribute to the overall eerie atmosphere.
Romantic Subplot: The romantic subplot between Jane and one of the male characters adds an additional layer to the story. While some readers find it predictable or cliché, others enjoy the tension and chemistry between the two characters.
Mixed Reactions to Certain Aspects: Some readers express mixed feelings about certain aspects of the book. For example, some find the characterization of Jane inconsistent or lacking depth. Others find the portrayal of certain characters, such as Lucky, problematic or unrealistic.

Reasons for Recommendation

Strong Characterization: Readers recommend "Dark Companion" for its well-developed characters. Jane Williams' resilience and determination shine through, making her a relatable and likable protagonist. The supporting characters add depth and humor to the story, making them memorable and enjoyable to read about.
Engaging Plot: The mysterious plot of "Dark Companion" keeps readers hooked from start to finish. The gradual reveal of secrets and twists keeps readers guessing and invested in the story's outcome. The gradual build-up of tension and suspense adds to the overall enjoyment of the book.
Gothic Atmosphere: The Gothic atmosphere of "Dark Companion" adds to its appeal for readers who enjoy dark and eerie stories. The atmospheric setting creates a sense of unease and intrigue that enhances the overall reading experience.
Romantic Subplot: While some readers find the romantic subplot predictable or cliché, others appreciate the tension and chemistry between the characters. The romantic subplot adds an additional layer to the story, making it more complex and engaging for readers who enjoy romance in their fiction.

Reasons for Not Recommending

Inconsistent Characterization: Some readers find the characterization of Jane inconsistent or lacking depth. They feel that her actions and decisions do not always align with her background or personality traits, making her less relatable and believable as a character.
Problematic Portrayal: Some readers express concerns about certain characters, such as Lucky, being problematic or unrealistic. They find his behavior towards Jane unacceptable or unbelievable, which detracts from their enjoyment of the book.

Conclusion

"Dark Companion" by Marta Acosta is a young adult novel that combines elements of mystery, Gothic fiction, and romance. Readers praise its strong characterization, engaging plot, and atmospheric setting. While some aspects may not resonate with all readers, overall, "Dark Companion" is recommended for those who enjoy stories with complex characters, intriguing mysteries, and a touch of darkness.