Quick Take

This rhyming picture book encourages children to celebrate their individuality and lets them know that it's okay to play with whatever toys they want to!Girls perform to fairy songs.Boys play football all day long.Boys yell, "Boo!" and run away. Girls like kittens and ballet. Except when they don't. Children are often told by many different people about what toys they're supposed to play with, what interests they should have, and who they should be simply because of their gender. This stereotype-breaking book invites children to examine what they're told "boy" and "girl" activities are and encourages them to play with whatever they want to and to be exactly who they are! This book is published in partnership with GLAAD to accelerate LGBTQ inclusivity and acceptance.

Reader's Review

Book Review Summary: Except When They Don't

Introduction

In the world of children's literature, books that challenge gender stereotypes and promote individuality are becoming increasingly popular. "Except When They Don't" by Laura Gehl is a rhyming picture book that encourages children to break free from the constraints of traditional gender roles and embrace their unique identities. With its vibrant illustrations and powerful message, this book has captured the hearts of readers and sparked conversations about gender norms. In this article, we will delve into the book's summary, author background, analysis of views, reasons for recommendation, and reasons for not recommending it.

About Laura Gehl

Laura Gehl, the author of "Except When They Don't," is a talented writer known for her engaging picture books. She has a knack for crafting stories that resonate with young readers and inspire them to explore their own identities. Gehl's previous works include the popular "Peep and Egg" series, which has received critical acclaim for its imaginative storytelling and relatable characters. With her latest book, Gehl continues to push boundaries and empower children to be themselves.

Analysis of Views

Celebrates Individuality: Readers appreciate the book's celebration of individuality and its encouragement for children to play with whatever toys they want. The message of breaking down gender stereotypes resonates with parents and educators who value diversity and inclusivity.
Engaging Rhyming Style: The book's rhyming narrative makes it an enjoyable read, both for children and adults. The rhythm and flow of the text help to keep readers engaged and create a memorable reading experience.
Powerful Message: The book's powerful message about being true to oneself and embracing one's individuality is a refreshing change from traditional gender norms. Many readers find the book's message inspiring and empowering for young readers.
Illustrations: The book's vibrant illustrations by Joshua Heinsz add depth and visual interest to the story. The colorful artwork captures the essence of the book's message, making it visually appealing to children.
Limited Addressing of Non-Binary/Gender-Bending Kids: Some readers feel that the book could have done a better job addressing non-binary or gender-bending kids explicitly. They believe that the book should have provided more language and representation for these children.

Reasons for Recommendation

Challenges Gender Stereotypes: "Except When They Don't" challenges traditional gender norms and encourages children to break free from limitations imposed by society. The book promotes individuality and self-expression, making it an excellent resource for parents and educators seeking to foster a more inclusive environment.
Engaging Narrative: The book's rhyming style and engaging narrative make it an enjoyable read for both children and adults. The story is easy to understand and relatable, making it accessible to a wide range of readers.
Inspiring Message: The book's message of self-acceptance and individuality is uplifting and empowering for young readers. It encourages children to embrace their unique qualities and pursue their passions without fear of judgment or conformity.

Reasons for Not Recommendation

Limited Representation: Some readers feel that the book could have done a better job addressing non-binary or gender-bending kids explicitly. They believe that the book should have provided more language and representation for these children to ensure a more inclusive reading experience.
Risky Beginning: A few readers have expressed concerns about the book's opening section, which lists traditional "boy" and "girl" activities. They feel that this section may be damaging if young children are reading it or if the book is read aloud without time to cover the entire content. They suggest that the book should have been more explicit in its message to avoid potential confusion or misinterpretation.

Conclusion

"Except When They Don't" by Laura Gehl is a rhyming picture book that challenges gender stereotypes and promotes individuality in childhood play. With its engaging narrative, vibrant illustrations, and powerful message, this book has garnered praise from readers who appreciate its efforts in breaking down rigid gender norms. While some readers have expressed concerns about the limited representation of non-binary or gender-bending kids and the risky beginning section, overall, "Except When They Don't" is recommended for parents, educators, and anyone seeking to foster a more inclusive environment for young readers. By encouraging children to be themselves and celebrating their unique qualities, this book contributes to a world where individuality is celebrated and gender stereotypes are challenged.