Bookishpedia
HomeGenresAll BooksAbout us
Cover image of The Trumpet of the Swan
The Trumpet of the Swan
E.B. White
ClassicsFictionChildrensFantasy
Quick Take
Louis is scared when his father tells him that he's different from other swans. He doesn't want to be different. Even though he can't talk, Louis knows he could learn to read and write, if only he could get into school.Sam Beaver, a boy who understands all wild things, agrees to help. But Mrs. Hammerbotham isn't sure she can handle a Trumpeter Swan in her classroom.
Reader's Review

Book Review Summary: The Trumpet of the Swan

Introduction

"The Trumpet of the Swan" by E.B. White is a beloved children's book that has captivated readers of all ages. Louis, the protagonist, is a trumpeter swan born without a voice, and he embarks on a journey to find a way to communicate with the world around him. With its humor, adventure, and heartwarming messages, this book has left a lasting impact on readers. In this article, we will explore the book's author, analyze common opinions and feelings of different readers, and summarize the reasons why it is highly recommended.

About E.B. White

E.B. White, the author of "The Trumpet of the Swan," was a renowned American essayist, author, humorist, poet, and literary stylist. He graduated from Cornell University in 1921 and joined the staff of "The New Yorker" magazine. White authored over seventeen books of prose and poetry, including "Charlotte's Web," "Stuart Little," and "The Trumpet of the Swan." He was elected to the American Academy of Arts and Letters in 1973 and received numerous awards for his literary contributions. White's writing style was characterized by its wit, humor, and ability to capture the essence of childhood experiences.

Analysis of Views

  1. Humor and Over-the-Top Florid Speeches: Readers appreciate the book's humor, particularly Louis' over-the-top florid speeches. They find it amusing how Louis, a swan, struggles with everyday human tasks like drawing curtains or using a telephone. The humor adds lightness to the story and creates moments of laughter.

  2. Lessons on Celebrating Differences and Coping with Disabilities: Many readers find "The Trumpet of the Swan" to be a valuable book that teaches children about celebrating differences and learning ways to cope with disabilities. Louis' determination to overcome his disability and find his voice resonates with readers, inspiring them to embrace their own unique qualities.

  3. Adventure and Nature Lesson: The book's adventurous elements and Louis' exploration of the natural world are also highly praised by readers. They enjoy following Louis as he navigates his environment and learns about swans and their behaviors. The book serves as an educational tool, introducing children to the wonders of nature.

  4. Morality and Ethical Dilemmas: Some readers find that "The Trumpet of the Swan" raises moral and ethical questions about the characters' actions. For example, Louis' agreement to give up some number of his future offspring as "sacrifices" to the zoo is seen as problematic by some readers. They question whether such actions are justifiable in the context of the story.

  5. Comparison to Other Works by E.B. White: Readers often compare "The Trumpet of the Swan" to other works by E.B. White, such as "Charlotte's Web." While some find it less heartbreaking than "Charlotte's Web," they still appreciate its charm and enjoyable narrative. However, some readers feel that it falls short compared to "Charlotte's Web" in terms of emotional depth and impact.

Reasons for Recommendation

  1. Humorous Storytelling: Readers recommend "The Trumpet of the Swan" for its humor and lightheartedness. The book's ability to make readers laugh through Louis' over-the-top speeches and quirky situations adds enjoyment to the reading experience.

  2. Inspiring Message: The book's message about celebrating differences and overcoming obstacles resonates with readers of all ages. Louis' determination to find his voice and pursue his dreams serves as an inspiration for children and adults alike.

  3. Nature Education: The book introduces children to the natural world and provides valuable insights into swans and their behaviors. It serves as an educational tool that fosters curiosity and appreciation for nature.

Reasons for Not Recommendation

  1. Lack of Emotional Depth: Some readers find that "The Trumpet of the Swan" lacks emotional depth compared to other works by E.B. White, such as "Charlotte's Web." They feel that the story does not elicit the same level of emotional connection as other beloved children's books.

  2. Moral Concerns: A few readers express moral concerns about certain aspects of the book, such as Louis' agreement to give up some number of his future offspring as "sacrifices" to the zoo. These concerns may prevent some readers from fully enjoying the story or recommend it to others.

Conclusion

"The Trumpet of the Swan" by E.B. White is a delightful children's book that combines humor, adventure, and heartwarming messages. With its engaging narrative and memorable characters, it has captured the hearts of readers young and old. While some readers appreciate its humor and inspiring message, others find it lacking in emotional depth compared to other works by E.B. White. Nonetheless, "The Trumpet of the Swan" remains a beloved classic that continues to captivate readers with its unique blend of fantasy, nature education, and moral exploration.

About us
Terms of use
Privacy Policy